International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education
Editors: A/Prof John Lidstone, Queensland University of Technology and Prof Joseph P. Stoltman, Western Michigan University
Book Review Editor: Dr Sarah Witham Bednarz, Texas A & M University
Editorial Assistant: Donna Bennett, Australia
|
Volume: 15 Number: 1 Page: 1–14
doi:10.2167/irgee183.0
|
|
|
|
|
A Content Comparison of Six Physical Geography Textbooks Spanning a Century
|
Steven A. Jennings
Department of Geography and Environmental Studies, University of Colorado at Colorado Springs, 1420 Austin Bluffs Parkway, Colorado Springs, CO 80918, Colorado, USA
|
|
Six physical geography textbooks published between 1901 and 2002 were qualitatively analysed for content and compared to the National Geography Standards. General relationships to dominant approaches to geography, content, and pedagogy of these textbooks were analysed. These textbooks reflect dominant approaches to geography at the time they were published. Content reflected the research findings of that time and the technology available. While the National Geography Standards post-date all but one of the textbooks, a comparison of content was made using the 18 standards. There was relatively good representation of the standards with the number of standards represented per textbook varying from 10 to 14. Based on this analysis recommendations for the development of future textbooks are made. These include addressing societal needs, the diversification of textbook material, and the implications of new technologies on textbooks.
Keywords: geography education, history of geographic thought, physical geography textbooks, US National Geography Standards
© 2006 S.A. Jennings
Access this article
|
